Golden, flaky, and full of buttery flavor–take your baked goods to perfection with an all butter pie crust that’s versatile and freezes great.Jump to Recipe
For years I made a basic pie crust with vegetable shortening. It’s the way I was taught and what I thought was best.
Then I learned two pivotal lessons:
- Vegetable oil and shortening is not what you want to eat . You can read why we quit it here.
- A butter pie crust is doggone delicious, more flaky and more delicate than it’s shortening version. I made my first one for an apple slab pie and I kid you not–it changed my pie baking life.
How to make a pie crust with butter step-by-step
Step 1: Put your favorite brand of all purpose flour in a bowl with salt and sugar (the sugar is optional–for savory recipes leave it out). Mix those together with a fork.
Step 2: Use a box grater to grate cold butter into the flour mixture. You can use two forks or two butter knives to cut the butter in also if it’s easier for you. I find a box grater to be the easiest way. Toss the butter gently with the flour to separate any large lumps.
Step 3: Add cold water and mix to form a ball of dough. Try not to over mix it. Work in any dry pockets of flour from the bottom of the bowl and avoid adding any more water. Wrap in plastic wrap and chill the dough about 15 minutes before moving on. This makes the dough easier to work with.
Step 4: Once your dough is chilled, divide the dough in half and roll one half about 1/4″ thick. Use a knife to cut a circle that’s 2-3 inches wider than your baking dish. If your dish is deep make sure to add extra so your dough fits. You can always trim off the extra after you get it in.
To place your dough in your dish, starting at the top, lay your rolling pin on the dough and gently fold the dough over the pin. Roll the dough very loosely around the pin and lift into your dish.
Step 5: Fit your dough to your dish and trim away any excess dough to about 1″ over the edge of your dish. Fold that 1″ under so it’s even with the edge of your pie dish. Use a fork to press lines into the dough, or use your fingers to crimp the dough. Bake according to your specific recipe.
Need some great pie crust recipes? Try these:
Chicken Pot Pie (leave out the sugar for this one)
All Butter Pie Crust
- In a large bowl, add the flour, salt and sugar and stir to combine.
- Use a box grater to grate the butter into the flour. Toss to coat and separate the pieces, breaking up anything larger than pea sized.
- Add the cold water and stir to combine. You may need to use your hands to work the dough together. There will be crumbly bits of flour in the bottom of the bowl; just press the dough down into those places until all the dry flour has been incorporated. In total this should take no longer than a minute.
- Divide the dough in half, press into a disc shape and wrap in plastic wrap. Chill 30 minutes or up to a week before using. Dough also freezes well tightly wrapped for up to 6 weeks.